Skip to main content

LHC grants bail in Libya boat tragedy case, rules bank transfer alone not proof of smuggling

The Lahore High Court (LHC) on Saturday granted post-arrest bail to a man accused in a human-smuggling case linked to a boat that capsized off the Libyan coast, killing 73 migrants. The court held that a mere transfer of money into an accused's bank account is not sufficient evidence of guilt unless it is directly tied to his knowing involvement or to an organised criminal network. Justice Muhammad Amjad Rafiq, deciding the bail petition of Muhammad Tahir, observed that investigators had established only that funds were routed through an account bearing the petitioner's name, the Madina Traders account, but had themselves found that the account was actually operated and controlled by a third party, Akbar Ali of Gojra. That finding, the court said, left the prosecution's case against Tahir without the evidence needed to link him either to an organised smuggling group or to show he had received the money with active knowledge of its purpose. On that basis, the court held the petitioner had made out a case for further inquiry and ordered his release on bail against surety bonds of Rs0.5 million. The tragedy behind the case The case stems from the sinking of a migrant boat off Libya on the night between April 5 and 6, 2026, in which 73 people died, including a young man named Ameer Hamza Shoukat. According to the FIR lodged by his brother, Kamran Shoukat, Hamza had been persuaded in 2025 by an alleged agent, Luqman Hakeem of Tehsil Phalia, District Mandi Bahauddin, who promised to arrange his travel to Italy for Rs3.5 million. Read: 50 migrants feared lost off Libya The family said they paid instalments into several accounts, including one linked to Khurram Shahzad, another to Zohaib Haider, one to AK Air Travels, and Rs0.9 million to the Madina Traders account associated with Tahir. Hamza was allegedly routed to Libya via Saudi Arabia, where he was held captive and further ransom payments were demanded before the fatal voyage. The FIR was registered at Police Station FIA CC, Gujrat, under provisions of the Emigration Ordinance, 1979, and the Prevention of Smuggling of Migrants Act, 2018. Defence and prosecution arguments Tahir's counsel argued that his client had never met the complainant or the victim, and that his alleged role rested on a single financial transaction, one that investigators themselves had traced back to Akbar Ali's control. He contended that instead of pursuing the case's transnational dimensions through mutual legal assistance or cross-border tracing, the agency had settled for weaker circumstantial links, and had additionally sought to invoke anti-money-laundering charges as what he called a routine fallback when direct evidence is lacking. Read more: Convictions of Libya deportees rise to 64 The assistant attorney general, representing the state, argued that the unexplained transfer of funds into the petitioner's account itself raised a presumption of complicity that called for an explanation from the accused. The court noted, however, that this argument did not address the case's international dimension; no request for cooperation with foreign counterparts, and no reference to the criminal networks operating out of Libya, appeared on record. In a detailed order, the judge laid out the evidentiary standard required to establish a prima facie case under the 2018 Act, describing it as a "51% likelihood" threshold that investigators must meet through admissible proof rather than suspicion alone. The judgment set out, section by section, what investigators are expected to gather in smuggling cases, from documentary and digital evidence such as ledgers, travel documents and electronic communications, to call data records, site inspections and victim travel histories, to establish a suspect's "intentional" and active engagement in smuggling under Section 3 of the Act. Applying that standard, the court found the case against Tahir fell short: the prosecution had shown a transaction but not knowledge, control, or organisational involvement, which the law requires before a financial link alone can support a smuggling charge. The court granted bail on surety bonds of Rs0.5 million with one surety in the like amount, subject to conditions that the petitioner not tamper with evidence or threaten witnesses, not leave the court's territorial jurisdiction without permission, and surrender his passport while remaining available for investigation or trial. The court clarified that its observations were tentative and would not affect the merits of the case at trial, and that bail could be cancelled if misused.

from Pakistan News, Latest News Pakistan, Pakistan Headline | The Express Tribune https://ift.tt/k2GSs8Y

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Govt, PTI kick off second round of talks ahead of Oct 4 long march

The second round of talks between the government and the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf began on Saturday, with National Assembly (NA) Speaker Ayaz Sadiq chairing the session, according to a statement issued by the National Assembly (NA) on X. A day earlier, the first round of talks between the government and opposition concluded with the two sides deciding to meet again on Saturday (today) in the NA speaker’s chamber. The negotiations come amid continued tensions after PTI’s announcement of a long march towards Islamabad on September 27 that was rescheduled to October 4. Currently, the standoff between the federal and provincial governments remains unresolved. The speaker said the previous day’s session was held in a “very cordial atmosphere” and expressed hope that all sides would continue the dialogue in the same spirit. Sadiq also thanked members of the government, PPP and opposition for participating in the talks. حکومت، پ...

PTI dismisses PM Shehbaz's 'mere offer' for talks, says govt can initiate contact with opposition leadership

The Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) on Tuesday dismissed Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif's proposal for renewed talks as a "mere offer”, while saying that the government could contact leaders of the opposition in the National Assembly and Senate for negotiations if it were sincere. The statement came amid heightened political tensions in the country as the PTI's long march reached Kohat. Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa Chief Minister Sohail Afridi is leading the convoy, which began its march towards Islamabad on Sunday to demand the release of party founder Imran Khan and press the government over what PTI describes as broader political and constitutional grievances. The convoy is currently in Kohat after travelling through Lakki Marwat and Karak, and is expected to depart for Peshawar later today as the party continues its phased mobilisation towards the federal capital. PM Shehbaz earlier today renewed an offer of talks to the PTI, saying the government was prepared to ...

Pakistan rejects India's 'internal matter' claim on Kashmir at UN

Pakistan on Saturday rejected India's characterisation of Jammu and Kashmir as an internal matter, telling a United Nations General Assembly committee that the territory's final status remains unresolved and must be determined in accordance with the wishes of the Kashmiri people. Speaking during the general debate of the Third Committee of the 81st session of the UN General Assembly, Pakistan's First Secretary Sarfraz Ahmed Gohar said Islamabad rejected New Delhi's assertion that Jammu and Kashmir was an integral part of India. "Pakistan categorically rejects India's futile attempts to dismiss the Jammu and Kashmir dispute as a so-called internal matter," Gohar said, according to remarks shared by Pakistan's Permanent Mission to the UN. Pakistan categorically rejects India's futile attempts to dismiss the Jammu and Kashmir dispute as a so-called internal matter. Jammu and Kashmir is an internationally recognized disputed territory, and it...